Reconstruction on the Caerau Hillfort
No sooner had I announced my decision to lay down my pen concerning things Arthurian than some of my more devoted readers prodded me again (rather forcibly!) to explain why I ultimately decided to discard Illtud as the historical figure underlying Uther Pendragon.
I was going to let that pass - were it not for the fact that the ghost of the terribilis miles, the magister militum/princeps militum Illtud continues to haunt me.
Why?
Well, because it once seemed certain to me that the author of the Pa Gur, who places Mabon servant of Uther at the River Ely, clearly identified Illtud with Uther. Illtud had been captain of Pawl Penychen's soldiers. And the Ely was in the center of Penychen. The Siluran oppidum Caerau was there, as was the known Dark Age fort of Dinas Powis.
Now, as I've mentioned in a previous blog, the poet might have merely identified an originally separate personage named Uther Pendragon with Illtud because of the Latin titles/descriptors that had been given to the latter. Anything is possible in the Pa Gur, which is a work replete with folklore.
But is it likely that the poet did so? Isn't it much more likely that Uther Pendragon had been constructed out of those titles/descriptors and that at some point in the legend-building process the fact that Uther was Illtud had been forgotten?
Ultimately, I found myself forsaking Uther as Illtud for a few reasons:
1) The aforementioned possibility
2) The lack of corresponding details when comparing Uther's role as Arthur's father with the Life of St. Illtud
3) The incompatibility of Arthur's battles (which were all northern) with an Arthur in the southern theater
4) Geoffrey of Monmouth could have arbitrarily made Uther Arthur's father, especially as there is no evidence in the pre-Galfridian tradition supporting the notion that Uther was actually Arthur's father
BUT, there is a far more serious objection to Illtud as Arthur's father - one which I'd neglected to fully consider. This has to do with the relationship of Mabon with the Ambrosius of Campus Elleti in Penychen.
For the Ambrosius of Campus Elleti, as I've been able to show pretty conclusively, is not the historical figure of the name. Instead, the "Divine/Immortal One" is the Welsh Mabon, in this particular context a manifestation of the Irish Oengus mac Og (see https://youtu.be/oQ6a8VFQJvY?si=TgpdbQJxSmvgv34C). And that means that the Pa Gur's "Mabon servant of Uther Pendragon" points us in a direction away from lltud.
The following is from work I'd done years ago on Uther Pendragon as a poetic name/epithet for Ambrosius himself:
"What all of this tells me is that I might well have been right, all those years ago, when I proposed, only half-seriously, that Uther Pendragon was merely a title for Ambrosius Aurelianus. This latter "fictional" chieftain of Dinas Emrys was said to be (HB Chapter 48) rex magnus or the 'great king' among the Britains. His fort was that of the Red Dragon, symbolic of the British, so he was the de facto pen or "chief" of that particular beast. Also, Vortigern was said to have 'timore Ambrosii', dread of Ambrosius. One of the meanings of Uther (see GPC) is 'dreadful'. It was not difficult to see in this combination of facts the title Uther Pendragon.
To quote from Bruce's THE ARTHURIAN NAME DICTIONARY:
"After Geoffrey's chronicle, Ambrosius disappears from legend and romance for some time. The authors of the Prose Merlin and the Vulgate Cycle renamed him Pendragon [emphasis mine]. He resurfaces in the seventeenth century..."
Now, partly this can be explained by the Galfridian fusion of Ambrosius and Merlin at Dinas Emrys. As Merlin now played a prominent role, that of Ambrosius would naturally have been downplayed or even to have disappeared. However, it does not account for why the Pendragon epithet continued to be used as a separate character, and one plainly based on Ambrosius. Instead, this would seem to be confirmation of my idea that Ambrosius IS Uther Pendragon.
I also once pointed out that in medieval tradition, a comet marked the death of a king. That is was, therefore, extremely odd that Geoffrey of Monmouth has the comet appear heralding Ambrosius's death, but say the dragon-star represents Uther.
For the Red Dragon of Vortigern, I have this old article available:
So, is Uther Pendragon = Ambrosius of the Red Dragon?
This could be true in legend, but there are major problems with the chronology of such an argument. My own research has indicated that Ambrosius is a reflection either of St. Ambrose or his Gallic father of the same name or perhaps a conflation of both men. I also demonstrated
(see https://mistshadows.blogspot.com/2020/05/why-ambrosius-aurelianus-was-put-in.html) that if Ambrosius was ever in Britain, it happened in the 4th century under the Emperor Constans. The statement in the HISTORIA BRITTONUM that has Ambrosius fight the grandfather of Vortigern supports this view.
If Arthur were thought to be the son of Ambrosius of the 4th century, then plainly Arthur could not have been fighting in the 5th-6th centuries.
As a final note, the fact that in CULHWCH AND OLWEN Arthur's father's kin are said to be at Caer Dathal/Dinas Emrys (https://mistshadows.blogspot.com/2021/01/dinas-emrys-as-caer-dathal-late.html?m=1) suggests once again that Uther should properly be identified with Ambrosius."
It makes a great deal of sense for someone to have made Ambrosius Arthur's father. These two chieftains had, after all, been given prominence in the HISTORIA BRITTONUM.
However, we can't very well identify Mabon as the servant of Uther with Uther himself!
And I'd already shown that Mabon as servant of Uther at Ely in what was part of Glywysing seemed to match up quite well with Mabon as prisoner of Eldad/Illtud at Caer Gloyw/Gloucester in CULHWCH AND OLWEN (https://mistshadows.blogspot.com/2024/10/illtud-knight-rides-again.html?m=1). It was, of course, Geoffrey of Monmouth who assigned Illtud of Glywysing to Gloucester, given that Glywys, the eponym of Glywysing, meant "man of Glevum" or "man of Gloucester."
It would thus appear, then, that as far as the Pa Gur poet is concerned, Uther = Illtud.
Okay, that is well and good. We can assume he was correct. But we then must accept the Galfridian use of Uther as Arthur's father. If we do that, then we are looking at an Arthur in southern England, and not northern England and Scotland. Most of the Arthurian battle sites - at least as I've identified them - would be bogus campaigns. They would have been drawn from wherever (Breguoin from Urien's Brewyn, for example, and far northern contests from those of the Dalriadan Arthur) and used to pad out Arthur's claimed victory at Badon (Bath as an error for Liddington Castle/Badbury/Durocornovium; see https://mistshadows.blogspot.com/2023/01/illtuds-father-bicanus-and-his-llydaw.html?m=1) and death at Camlan (given the Medard = Medraut business of the ANNALES CAMBRIAE, Camlan is probably Cymenesora/Selsey Bill; see https://mistshadows.blogspot.com/2025/06/medrawd-medard-and-death-of-arthur.html?m=1).
This scenario will appear attractive to many people - and I cannot in good conscience gainsay it. The name Arthur need not be traced directly to the 3rd century L. Artorius Castus. It may have come to southern Wales by any number of ways, including with the Latin merely having been adopted as a deckname for a previous British arth-/"bear" name. The Welsh themselves saw arth in Arthur, and I've suggested that Barbury Castle near Liddington, the "Bear's fort", may represent an English memory of Arthur having been present there.
I'm convinced that my treatment of the tradition does show that Uther = Illtud. But was Illtud Arthur's father?
Well, who knows? We have no other viable option in the tradition, so far as I can determine. But knowing Geoffrey of Monmouth 'the Great Fabricator' as well as I do, my gut tells me he co-opted Uther Pendragon, whose identification with Illtud had been forgotten or intentionally obscured, by transforming him into Arthur's father.
***
The best reading of the Castus memorial stone's ARM[...]S lacuna remains not my clever ARM.GENTES, but ARMENIOS. That Castus went to Armenia with Statius Priscus, the Roman governor of Britain, and became procurator of Liburnia c.168-170, the only known time Dalmatia was reorganized militarily, fits history the best.
I'm posting below a conversation I had only recently with Prof. Dr. Peter Kovacs that presents new evidence for a total lack of such a reorganization of Dalmatia under Caracalla during his German Wars - something I once tried to make a case for.
Hello, Dr. Kovacs.
I'm writing to you as you are the author of 2012. ‘Der Besuch von Caracalla in Pannonien’ AArchHung 63, 381-94.
More recently, your study was cited in this work:
Re-Evaluating the Chronology of Caracalla's Reign: When Was Caracalla in Nikomedia?
October 2022 Classica et Mediaevalia 71:75-103
Mads Ortving Lindholmer
I apologize that even were I able to obtain your article, due to my ignorance of your language I would not be able to read it.
Would you mind, please, perhaps answering a couple of questions - no matter how briefly?
1) Can you kindly summarize what kind or reorganization was undertaken by Caracalla in Pannonia?
2) Is there any chance northern Dalmatia was affected by this reorganization?
My question has to do with two competing opinions regarding the founding of the temporary province of Liburnia. Consensus seems to regard this as happening either when Marcus Aurelius and Lucius Verus reorganized Illyricum c. 168-170 at the outset of the Marcomannic Wars or that the division of Dalmatia might have occurred at the time of the Germanic Wars of Caracalla. We do know Caracalla refortified the German limes, but I was unaware of his possible activities in Pannonia.
Thank you, best wishes, and respectfully,
Daniel Hunt
Hi Daniel,
No, Dalmatia was not affected during Caracalla's German Wars.
Brigetio and its territory and the legio I adiutrix was attached in 213 to Pannonia inferior from Pannonia superior and Lower Pannonia became a province with two legions and consular legate (instead of a praetorian).
The argumentation of Speidel is more plausible than that of Lindholmer. He has Caracalla returning to Europe in 214.
Güney-Doğu Avrupa Araştırmaları Dergisi - The Journal of Southeastern European Studies, 40 (2023): 87-96
DOI: 10.26650/gaad.2023007
Research Article
Caracalla’s journeys through the Balkans in 213 and 214
You can also check my book A history of Pannonia during the Principate in English.
Best,
Prof. Dr. Péter Kovács
Piliscsaba H-2081 Hungary
Kossuth Lajos u. 65
Why does this matter?
Because a prefect of the Sixth who did not take part in a memorable campaign in North Britain as commander of legionary troops is unlikely to be the figure behind the famous Arthur. The Britons could care less that such a prefect took troops to Armenia, never to return.
On the other hand, the province of Liburnia might have continued to exist for some time. There is no reason to assume that Castus was the first procurator of the province. He could have governed the region during any period of its existence. There seems to be a sort of educated guess that Liburnia ceased to exist around 180, when Commodus put an end to the Marconmannic Wars. But it is just as possible it was thought to no longer be needed once Pannonia was reinforced. If so, then the terminus of Liburnia might well have occurred in 213/214. Given that the British war was concluded by Caracalla in 211, it is quite conceivable that Castus was procurator of Liburnia for the intervening years.
I asked Prof. Kovac about this. His response:
"It is quite possible that the separate province of Liburnia ended with the massive reorganization of neighboring Pannonia. So, yes, Castus could have been Liburnian procurator immediately following the Severan campaign in Britain. We would expect a regular senatorial governor (legate) of Dalmatia to have been in control of the southern part of the province at the same time."
Prof. Kovacs was kind enough to provide me with the relevant section on Caracalla and Pannonia from his book (cited above). I’m pasting that here:
“Pannonia under Caracalla and the emperor’s visit to the province (211-217
AD)
The communis opinio in international Pannonia studies is that sometime after the Alamannic campaign in 213/214, the Emperor Caracalla visited Pannonia, suffering at the time from Barbarian raids, and that this visit had major repercussions regarding the province ’s administration; concurrently, major construction work was undertaken on the forts of the limes system and its most important sanctuaries, at least on the testimony of the epigraphic material,
problematic matters in the alliance system by simply having the Quadic king and
some of his followers executed on the spot. However, a closer look at the relevant sources indicates that the occasion of the “imperial visit” is not as straightforward as it might first appear...
Caracalla had indeed passed through Pannonia in the autumn of 213, but
owing to the brevity of time, he did not stop for long in any one place. This can
hardly be regarded as an imperial visit with the intention of inspecting the province and thus the inscriptions dating from Caracalla’s reign can hardly all be dated to the autumn of 213. Obviously, Caracalla’s predilection for founding new towns and for new constructions (Dio LXXVII.13.4), as well as the epithet Antoniniana of the municipium of Brigetio (RIU 450) may have led to instructions to reconstruct the forts of the limes system and of major sanctuaries, but it seems unlikely that he had personally inspected the finished work.
Passing through the two Pannonias, the emperor probably became aware of
the unnecessary differentiation between the provinces and the three legions in
Pannonia superior may have been perceived as representing too strong a force (cf. the division of Britain and Syria two decades earlier). The border modification was no doubt a direct result of this, even if the task itself was left to Suetrius Sabinus, who as iudex vice Caesaris executed the task assigned to him the next year.
The revision of the border under Caracalla
The province of Pannonia superior, which played such a crucial role in securing the throne for Septimius Severus, was the Empire’s last province to be garrisoned by three legions. Syria, supporting his adversaries, and Britain had been divided during his lifetime (Her. III.5.1, III.8.2, Dio LV.23.2).1151 Caracalla and his retinue probably became aware of this situation during their journey through Pannonia and decided that it would be safer to decrease the number of legions to two. This could be easily achieved by redrawing the province’s borders and by attaching the legio adiutrix in Brigetio to Pannonia inferior, whereby the two Pannonias each became a two-legion province governed by a consularis.U 52 There are two possibilities for determining the date of the revision: (1) the date from which the legio adiutrix became a unit of Pannonia inferior, and (2) the date from which the governors of Pannonia inferior were consulares. We have relatively accurate data at our disposal for answering both questions. In 212, the speculatores of the legio I adiutrix still set up an altar in Carnuntum jointly with the speculatores of the other two legions of
Pannonia superior (CIL III 4452 = 11093 = ILS 2382), while in 228, the altar was
erected in Aquincum (CIL III 3524 = Tit. Aq. 9). In 224, the benéficiarii of the legio 1 and II adiutrix erected an altar jointly in the beneficiarius sanctuary of Sirmium (AÉp 1994, 1417). In Cassius Dio’s list of the legions, the legion is described as being quartered in Pannonia inferior (LV.24.2). There is also ample evidence regarding the governors. We know that Suetrius Sabinus had assumed the governorship of Pannonia inferior as a former consul (cos. ord. 214) during Caracalla’s lifetime (probably already in 214).1153 The re-division of the province can probably be dated to 214 AD, when Suetrius Sabinus dealt with some legal matters as index vice Caesaris (CIL X 5178: [iudex ex] delegatu [pjrincipum (!) in provincia [Pannonia superiore item] inferiore, CIL X 5398: iudex ex dele[g(atu)] cognition(um) Caesarian(arum) ), as the emperor’s deputy during the ruler’s absence. The inscriptions indicate that the place of his appointment can be securely located to Pannonia superior and inferior.1154 The raison d’etre of his appointment could hardly have been anything else than the redrawing of the province’s border, a decision brought during the emperor’s brief sojourn in Pannonia. The inscribed basis from Aquincum set up by Sabinus (CIL III 10490 = AÉp 2000, 1219 = Tit. Aq. 23) probably represents a relic from this period. The areas actually affected by the revision are still subject to heated debates. What seems certain is that Brigetio and its territorium and the assumed municipium of Mogiones in the Kömye area became part of Pannonia inferior, while the appearance of the inscriptions of the legio II adiutrix (RIU 337, 343, 1419, AÉp 1969-1970, 469: a vessel inscribed by a soldier of the legio II adiutrix from Baldca, perhaps from the imperial estate centre"55), the auxiliary troops from Pannonia inferior (RIU 365, 1414) and the magistrates of Aquincum (RIU 356, 1421, TRHR 70) suggests that together with the Balaton Uplands, Mogetiana was also incorporated into Pannonia inferior."56 In contrast, Arrabona and its broader region was not annexed to Pannonia inferior despite the milestones set up under the supervision of the governors of Pannonia inferior (AÉp 1996, 1247-1248),1157 given that an inscription from Rome (CIL VI 36351) describes Arrabona as lying in Pannonia superior."58 The new border probably extended between Ad Statuas/Ad Mures and Brigetio along the limes.1159”
So, I suppose the matter of when the province of Liburnia came to an end comes down to this:
although we could make a case for it ending c. 180, when Commodus ended the Marcomannic Wars, we are left to wonder if the Emperor felt sufficiently confident in the new peace with his troublesome northern neighbors to revert Dalmatia to its pre-wartime footing. This would seem to be an unwise move, given that no additional fortification or military reorganization had yet been undertaken in Pannonia. Granted, Commodus did refortify the German limes. But what if that was broken through and Liburnia no longer stood between Rome and barbarian invaders?
With a new limes established in Pannonia under Caracalla, however, it may well have been considered unnecessary to leave Liburnia as a separate bulwark from the rest of the old province. If this is when Liburnia as a distinct province ceased to be, we might well have Castus be the last procurator there, rather than the first.
POSTSCRIPT
I have gone over the details of my Arthurian battle site identifications one last time, with a very critical eye. They are solid. And they run along Dere Street, one of its short branches in Lowland Scotland and its Gask Ridge extension in the Highlands.
That only fits a Roman general.
As we have one such named Artorius, and the HB battles are our earliest source for Arthur, I must default to Castus.
After some 30 years, I'm suspending my search.




